Contact us

How to Scope a Penetration Test: A Step-by-Step Guide

Imagine commissioning a custom-built house without providing blueprints, specifications, or even a clear idea of how many rooms you need. The result would likely be chaos, wasted resources, and a structure that utterly fails to meet your expectations. The same principle applies, perhaps even more critically, to penetration testing. While the allure of a “hack-me-if-you-can” scenario is exciting, diving into a penetration test without a meticulously defined scope is akin to embarking on a high-stakes mission without a map or clear objectives.

A poorly defined scope is a leading cause of penetration test failures, whether that means missing critical vulnerabilities, exceeding budgets, encountering legal complications, or simply receiving a report that doesn’t address your real security concerns. It can lead to frustration for both your organization and the testing vendor, ultimately diminishing the value of a potentially invaluable security exercise.

Scoping a penetration test isn’t just a formality; it’s the foundational phase that dictates the entire trajectory, effectiveness, and ultimate value of your security assessment. It’s the process of clearly outlining what will be tested, why it’s being tested, how it will be tested, and what success looks like. This guide will walk you through the essential steps to define a precise and actionable scope for your next penetration test, ensuring a targeted, efficient, and truly valuable security assessment.

The “Why” Before the “What”: Understanding Your Motivation

Before you even begin to list IP addresses or application URLs, the very first step in effective scoping is to clearly articulate why you’re commissioning a penetration test. The underlying motivation profoundly influences the type of test, its objectives, and ultimately, its scope. Without this clarity, your test might identify vulnerabilities, but they might not be the ones that truly matter to your business.

Let’s explore the common drivers:

  • Compliance Requirements: This is a frequent and often non-negotiable driver. Various regulatory frameworks mandate penetration testing, but their requirements can differ significantly in terms of scope, frequency, and methodology.
    • PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard): Requires both internal and external penetration tests of the Cardholder Data Environment (CDE) and segmentation validation. The scope here is tightly defined around cardholder data flows. (For a deep dive into these requirements, see: Penetration Testing for PCI DSS Compliance: What You Need to Know).
    • HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act): While not explicitly mandating “penetration tests,” HIPAA’s Security Rule requires comprehensive risk analyses and the implementation of technical safeguards to protect Electronic Protected Health Information (ePHI). Penetration testing is an indispensable tool for fulfilling these mandates by identifying vulnerabilities to ePHI. (Learn how pen testing fits with HIPAA in: HIPAA and Penetration Testing: Securing PHI the Right Way).
    • CMMC (Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification) & NIST 800-171: Defense contractors handling CUI (Controlled Unclassified Information) must comply with these frameworks. Penetration testing is crucial for validating security controls and identifying weaknesses that could compromise CUI. (Read more on this in: CMMC & NIST 800-171 Penetration Testing for Defense Contractors).
    • SOC 2 (System and Organization Controls 2): While not a direct mandate, penetration testing provides crucial evidence for the Security, Availability, and Confidentiality Trust Services Criteria, demonstrating robust control effectiveness. (Explore its role in SOC 2 here: Penetration Testing for SOC 2 and Other Attestation Frameworks).
    • GLBA (Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act) & FFIEC (Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council): Financial institutions face stringent requirements for protecting customer financial information, with penetration testing being a critical component of their risk management strategy. (Find out more about financial services requirements in: Penetration Testing for Financial Services: GLBA and FFIEC Requirements). If your primary driver is compliance, the scope will be heavily influenced by the specific requirements of the relevant regulation.
  • Risk Management: Beyond compliance, organizations conduct penetration tests to proactively manage risk. This might involve:
    • Addressing Specific Identified Risks: Following a risk assessment, if certain vulnerabilities or attack vectors are deemed high-risk, a targeted pen test can validate these risks and the effectiveness of existing controls.
    • Validating Security Controls: After implementing new security technologies (e.g., a new WAF, an EDR solution), a pen test can verify if they perform as expected under real attack conditions.
    • Post-Incident Assessment: If your organization has recently experienced a breach or a significant security incident, a penetration test can help identify the root cause, assess if similar vulnerabilities still exist, and confirm that remediation efforts have been effective.
    • Due Diligence for Cyber Insurance: Many cyber insurance providers require evidence of proactive security measures, including penetration tests, as part of their underwriting process. A strong test report can positively impact your premiums and coverage. (This is explored further in: The Role of Penetration Testing in Risk Management and Cyber Insurance).
  • Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A): When acquiring another company, a penetration test of the target entity’s infrastructure is crucial for understanding its security posture and identifying potential liabilities before integration.
  • New System/Application Deployment: Before a critical new application, system, or major infrastructure change goes live, a penetration test provides assurance that it’s secure against known attack vectors. This is especially true for customer-facing applications or systems handling sensitive data.
  • Continuous Improvement & Offensive Security Program: For mature organizations, penetration testing is an ongoing part of a broader offensive security program, aimed at continuously challenging and improving defensive capabilities and preparing the “Blue Team” for real threats. (Explore this concept in: Continuous Penetration Testing and the Future of Offensive Security).

Once you understand your primary motivation, you can move to the tangible aspects of scoping.

Step 1: Defining Your Assets (The “What to Test”)

This is arguably the most concrete and fundamental step in scoping. You need a comprehensive, granular list of exactly what the penetration testers are authorized to interact with. Ambiguity here is a recipe for disaster, potentially leading to critical assets being missed or, worse, unauthorized testing of systems that could cause disruption.

A. Comprehensive Inventory and Classification

Start by creating an exhaustive inventory of all relevant IT assets. This isn’t just a list; it requires classification based on criticality and data sensitivity.

  • 1. Network Infrastructure:
    • External IP Ranges: All public-facing IP addresses, including web servers, email servers, VPN endpoints, and cloud gateway IPs. Be precise with CIDR notations (e.g., 192.168.1.0/24).
    • Internal Subnets: If conducting an internal penetration test, specify the internal network segments, VLANs, and critical internal systems (e.g., Active Directory domains, DNS servers, critical databases).
    • Firewalls, Routers, Switches: The network devices that control traffic flow.
    • VPN Solutions: Ensure the VPN infrastructure itself is in scope if it’s a potential entry point.
    • DMZs (Demilitarized Zones): Any systems residing in a DMZ should be explicitly included.
  • 2. Applications:
    • Web Applications: Provide all relevant URLs (e.g., https://www.yourcompany.com, https://portal.yourcompany.com). Specify if there are different environments (staging, production) and which ones are in scope. Note any existing Web Application Firewalls (WAFs).
    • Mobile Applications: Specify platforms (iOS, Android), provide app store links or direct download links, and indicate if backend APIs are in scope.
    • APIs (Application Programming Interfaces): List all APIs, including documentation (Swagger/OpenAPI specs), and specify if they are public or internal.
    • Thick Clients/Desktop Applications: If your business relies on desktop applications that handle sensitive data or interact with critical backend systems, these should be included.
    • SaaS Integrations: If your organization heavily relies on SaaS solutions and has built custom integrations or configurations, the security of these integrations might be in scope.
    • Development & Testing Environments: Consider if these environments, especially if they contain production data or configurations, should be included to prevent insecure code from propagating to production.
  • 3. Servers & Endpoints:
    • Operating Systems: List the types of operating systems in use (Windows Server, Linux distributions, macOS for endpoints).
    • Databases: Specify database types (SQL Server, MySQL, PostgreSQL, Oracle) and their locations if they contain sensitive data.
    • Critical Servers: Include Domain Controllers, DNS servers, Email servers, file servers, SIEMs, authentication servers (e.g., RADIUS, Okta), and virtual machine hosts.
    • User Workstations/Endpoints: For internal tests, consider including a sample of user workstations to simulate a malware infection or compromised endpoint.
  • 4. Cloud Environments:
    • Cloud Providers: Specify AWS, Azure, GCP, or other cloud providers.
    • Account IDs/Subscription IDs: Provide the specific cloud accounts or subscriptions to be tested.
    • Cloud Services: List specific services in scope (e.g., AWS EC2 instances, S3 buckets, Lambda functions; Azure VMs, Blob Storage, Functions; GCP Compute Engine, Cloud Storage, App Engine).
    • Shared Responsibility Model: Crucially, understand and document the shared responsibility model. Penetration testers will focus on what your organization is responsible for securing (e.g., configurations, custom code) rather than the underlying cloud infrastructure (which is the cloud provider’s responsibility). (Our dedicated article, Cloud Penetration Testing: Securing AWS, Azure, and GCP, delves into this in detail).
  • 5. Wireless Networks:
    • SSIDs: List all corporate and guest Wi-Fi network names.
    • Authentication Methods: Specify WPA2-Enterprise, WPA3, open networks, etc.
    • Scope: Define if the test includes attempts to access the internal network from the wireless network, or just to assess the wireless network itself.
  • 6. Physical Locations:
  • 7. People:
    • Target Groups for Social Engineering: For social engineering tests (e.g., phishing campaigns), define the scope of employees or departments to be targeted. Provide email addresses or phone numbers if necessary. (Again, Understanding the Different Types of Penetration Tests offers more detail).

B. Determining the Attack Surface

Once you have your inventory, visualize the attack surface:

  • External-Facing Assets: What does an attacker see from the internet? These are usually your first priority for external pen tests.
  • Internal Assets: What could an insider or a compromised system access? These are the focus for internal pen tests.
  • Third-Party Integrations: Do you rely heavily on third-party APIs or cloud services? While you might not test the vendor’s systems, your integration points (API keys, authentication methods) might be in scope.

C. In-Scope vs. Out-of-Scope (Crucial for Clarity)

It is just as important to explicitly define what will NOT be tested as what will be. This prevents misunderstandings, avoids accidental disruption, and ensures the vendor focuses their efforts effectively.

  • Examples of Out-of-Scope: Production systems that cannot tolerate any downtime, systems managed by third parties (where you don’t have explicit permission to test), personal employee devices, or specific services that are intentionally segregated.
  • Whitelisting: Provide a list of source IP addresses that the testing team will use. Your IT/security team should whitelist these IPs in firewalls, WAFs, and IDS/IPS systems to prevent the test traffic from being blocked or triggering alarms (unless testing detection capabilities is an explicit objective).
  • Avoiding Disruption: Clearly state your tolerance for disruption. Most standard penetration tests aim to be non-disruptive, but certain attack vectors (e.g., denial of service simulations) are inherently disruptive and must be explicitly agreed upon and carefully controlled if included.

Step 2: Setting Clear Objectives (The “Why to Test” and “What Success Looks Like”)

Defining concrete objectives transforms a general security assessment into a focused, high-value exercise. Without clear objectives, the test becomes a fishing expedition, and the results may not align with your strategic security goals.

A. Primary Objectives

What do you want the penetration testers to achieve or prove?

  • 1. Identify and Validate Vulnerabilities: This is a universal objective. Be specific if possible. For example:
    • “Identify all OWASP Top 10 vulnerabilities in app.yourcompany.com.”
    • “Find all misconfigurations that could lead to unauthorized access to the internal network.”
    • “Discover all missing patches on critical Windows servers in the CDE.”
  • 2. Assess Configuration Weaknesses: Beyond just missing patches, focus on insecure configurations. E.g., “Determine if default credentials are in use on network devices,” or “Assess the security of Active Directory configurations against common attack patterns.”
  • 3. Test Security Controls: Evaluate the effectiveness of your security investments.
    • “Attempt to bypass the WAF protecting yourwebapp.com.”
    • “Verify if the IDS/IPS detects common exploitation attempts.”
    • “Test the robustness of multi-factor authentication (MFA) implementations.”
    • “Assess the effectiveness of endpoint detection and response (EDR) solutions.”
  • 4. Evaluate Incident Response Capabilities: For more advanced engagements, particularly Red Team engagements, a key objective is to test how well your security operations center (SOC) or incident response team detects, contains, and remediates the simulated attack. (This is the primary goal of a Red Team, detailed in: How Much Does a Red Team Engagement Cost?).
  • 5. Achieve Specific Goals (Attack Scenarios): Define realistic scenarios that mimic actual threats to your organization. This often involves a “flag” the testers are trying to capture.
    • “Gain Domain Administrator privileges within the internal network.”
    • “Exfiltrate a mock sensitive data file from the database server.”
    • “Access the segmented PCI CDE from the corporate network.”
    • “Perform a cross-site scripting (XSS) attack to compromise a user’s session in the patient portal.”
    • “Deploy persistent access on a critical server.”
    • “Bypass physical security controls to access the server room.”

B. Success Metrics

How will you measure the success of the penetration test? While the findings themselves are a success, defining metrics helps.

  • “Identification of at least X critical vulnerabilities.”
  • “Successful demonstration of Y attack path.”
  • “Validation that Z security control is effective.”
  • “A comprehensive report with actionable remediation advice.”

Step 3: Aligning with Compliance Goals (The “How to Meet Regulations”)

As discussed in the “Why” section, compliance is often a major driver. This step ensures your pen test scope directly addresses those regulatory requirements.

A. Mapping to Specific Requirements

Work closely with your internal compliance team or external auditors (e.g., your QSA for PCI DSS, your assessor for SOC 2) to ensure the penetration test scope and methodology directly map to the audit requirements.

  • PCI DSS: Ensure the scope covers all CDE components, segmentation validation, and application-layer testing (if applicable). The frequency (annually, semi-annually for segmentation) must be met.
  • HIPAA: The test should focus on systems handling ePHI and aim to identify vulnerabilities that could compromise the confidentiality, integrity, or availability of that data. The test report will serve as critical evidence for your risk analysis.
  • CMMC/NIST 800-171: The scope should align with the defined system boundaries for Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI) and test the effectiveness of relevant NIST 800-171 controls, contributing to your POA&M (Plan of Action and Milestones).
  • SOC 2: The pen test provides evidence for the “Security” principle (and potentially Availability and Confidentiality). The scope should cover systems relevant to these Trust Services Criteria.
  • GLBA/FFIEC: Financial institutions need to ensure pen tests address the security of customer financial data and align with FFIEC guidelines for information security.

B. Evidence Collection

Clarify with your penetration testing vendor what format the final report should take to serve as effective evidence for auditors. This might include specific sections, a clear executive summary, detailed technical findings, remediation recommendations, and a formal attestation from the testing firm.

C. Frequency and Timing

Compliance frameworks often dictate the frequency of penetration tests (e.g., annual, semi-annual). Ensure your scoping plan aligns with these timelines. Consider also the timing relative to major system changes or new deployments.

Step 4: Defining Rules of Engagement (The “How the Test Will Be Conducted”)

The Rules of Engagement (RoE) are the critical operational guidelines for the penetration test. They protect your organization, guide the testers, and ensure a smooth, controlled assessment. This is where you set the boundaries and communication protocols.

A. Communication Plan

  • Primary Points of Contact: Designate specific technical, management, and legal contacts on your team who will liaise with the testing vendor.
  • Emergency Contact Procedures: Establish clear protocols for immediate notification of critical findings (e.g., immediate root access, exfiltration of real sensitive data) or any accidental disruption to services. This should include phone numbers and escalation paths.
  • Regular Check-ins: Agree on the frequency of status updates (e.g., daily stand-ups, weekly summaries).
  • Preferred Communication Channels: (e.g., secure chat, email, phone calls).

B. Testing Methodology (Black Box, White Box, Gray Box)

Define the level of knowledge the testers will have before and during the engagement:

  • Black Box: The testers have no prior knowledge of your internal systems, network architecture, or credentials. This simulates an external, unknown attacker.
  • White Box: The testers are given full access to documentation, source code, network diagrams, and potentially credentials. This simulates an insider threat or provides a deep dive into specific application logic.
  • Gray Box: The most common approach, where testers are provided with some limited knowledge (e.g., standard user credentials, network diagrams) to balance realism with efficiency. (A detailed explanation of these methodologies is in: Understanding the Different Types of Penetration Tests).

C. Permissible Techniques and Prohibited Activities

Be explicit about what attack techniques are allowed and, just as importantly, what is strictly forbidden.

  • Allowed: Network scanning, vulnerability exploitation, web application attacks, password cracking (against hashes, not live systems if disruptive).
  • Prohibited: Denial of Service (DoS) attacks (unless specifically agreed upon for resilience testing in a controlled environment), social engineering against specific individuals, testing of third-party systems not explicitly in scope, or any activity that could cause service disruption without prior explicit approval.
  • Timing: Specify preferred hours for testing (e.g., business hours, off-hours, weekends) to minimize potential impact on operations.

D. Timeframes and Deliverables

  • Start and End Dates: Define the precise window for active testing.
  • Key Milestones: Outline when draft reports, final reports, and debriefings are expected.
  • Deliverables Format: Specify the desired format for the report (PDF, online portal), including executive summary, technical findings, and remediation steps.
  • Retesting: Clarify the process for retesting remediated vulnerabilities, including timelines and any associated costs. (This ties directly into: What Happens After a Penetration Test? Remediation, Retesting, and Lessons Learned).

This is critical to protect both your organization and the testing vendor.

  • Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs): Ensure an NDA is in place to protect your sensitive information.
  • Liability Clauses: Clearly define liability in the event of accidental damage or unauthorized actions.
  • Authorization Letter (Get-Out-of-Jail-Free Card): This is a formal, signed document from your organization explicitly authorizing the penetration testing company (and specific individuals if possible) to perform the defined activities. This letter should be carried by the testers (especially for physical tests) to present to law enforcement or your security team if alarms are triggered. It explicitly states that the activities are authorized and legal. Without this, security teams might treat testers as real attackers, leading to costly and stressful misunderstandings.

Working with Your Vendor on Scoping

While this guide provides a robust framework, scoping a penetration test is inherently a collaborative process between your organization and the chosen penetration testing vendor. A good vendor won’t just accept your initial scope; they’ll ask probing questions, challenge assumptions, and offer expert advice to refine it.

  • Seek Expertise: Choose a vendor with proven experience in your industry and with the specific types of assets and objectives you’ve identified. Their insights can be invaluable in crafting a practical and effective scope. (For guidance on selecting the right partner, refer to: How to Choose a Penetration Testing Vendor: Red Flags and Must-Haves).
  • Iterative Process: Be prepared for multiple discussions and revisions to the scope document before it’s finalized. This iterative process ensures mutual understanding and alignment.
  • Transparency: Provide the vendor with as much relevant information as possible within the confines of your security policies. The more they understand your environment and motivations, the more effective their testing will be.

Conclusion

Scoping a penetration test is far more than a checklist exercise; it is the strategic bedrock upon which a successful security assessment is built. It demands a clear understanding of your organizational goals, a meticulous inventory of your assets, a precise definition of objectives, and explicit rules of engagement.

Taking the time and effort to thoroughly define these parameters upfront is an investment that pays immense dividends. It ensures that the penetration test is targeted, efficient, legally sound, and, most importantly, yields actionable insights that genuinely enhance your organization’s security posture and address your specific risks and compliance obligations. Don’t view scoping as an administrative burden, but as a critical project phase that sets the stage for a productive partnership with your chosen vendor and ultimately, a more secure future for your organization.

Share:

More Posts